First off the bat, I would like to wish all my readers a very Happy New Year 2025! May this year be the year you achieve your dream goals or at least bring you a step closer to them! If those goals involve any sort of air travel to and from Canada, I hope my blog and channels equip you with the necessary information that enable you to achieve your travel goals.

During our holiday trip to Vancouver in December 2024, I had the opportunity to experience the much hyped Porter Reserve experience on board the Embraer E195-E2 Jet between Toronto and Vancouver. In this post, I would like to provide my review of the “what’s good?” and “what’s not so good?” on this experience. I find the Toronto – Vancouver route to be the best city pair to compare flying experiences for the following reasons:

  • Trip Duration: At about 4-5 hours of flying time, it gives the airline enough time to deliver a strong soft product (experience) to the customer
  • Competition: Both West Jet and Air Canada, the so called duopoly in Canada, have direct and one stop connections between the two cities. This enables a good evaluation of routing, frequencies, and flight scheduling time.

What’s Good?

The soft product

Without a doubt, the Porter Reserve Experience (i.e., meals, drink service, crew friendliness and promptness) was the best part about Porter. While both our flights (to and from Vancouver) were delayed significantly (more on that to follow), the crew wore a pleasant smile on their faces and served all passengers on board very well. Furthermore, the ~5 hour flying time has allowed Porter to craft a pleasant flying experience. 30 mins into the flight, the first drink service commenced. About 1 hour into the flight, the crew took orders for the main meal, which was served in a very neatly packed box. Halfway through the flight the crew came around with another round of drinks. About 1 hour before landing, the crew handed out a round of snacks.

Overall, I found the timing of the services to be well spaced, allowing passengers to rest while at the same time keeping them entertained and fed. Comparing the Porter Reserve service to AC and WS, I found myself seated in a “Premium Economy” cabin on AC, with AC having the slight edge over PD.

2-2 configuration: No middle seats

While the seat design itself could have been better, I found the 2-2 aircraft layout to be far superior than the 3-3 layout on most narrow bodies. This configuration on the E195-E2 aircraft ensures no middle seats, making it a more comfortable experience for the solo traveler and couples alike. More importantly, the specific model used by Porter is the Recaro SL3710 for economy seating and potentially a variation or customized version for PorterReserve to enhance passenger comfort. The seat did not cause any discomfort to me during the 5+ hours of flying time between YVR and YYZ.

Priority Perks: Check-in and Boarding

Porter Reserve includes priority check-in, boarding, and luggage handling. These time-saving benefits are particularly valuable when flying from a busy hub like Toronto Pearson. Although I found that the Porter ground staff were inconsistent in announcing the boarding order on the two instances that I flew Porter Reserve. At Toronto, the gate agents called for pre-boarding that included passengers with small children and anyone requiring additional time to get settled into the aircraft. This was followed by general economy seating. In contrast, the boarding order at Vancouver was appropriately called when Porter Reserve was called ahead of general boarding. Perhaps this is one of the areas that Porter needs to improve on.

What’s Not So Good?

Price Point

While Porter Reserve provides a premium experience, the ticket price can be steep compared to competitors offering similar services. Travelers on a budget might find it hard to justify the extra cost. I booked the Porter Reserve experience on the Amex Travel Portal when searching for Premium Economy flights. Although the price point for this “Premium Economy” ticket on PD was far lower than AC, it still is a steep bump up from the general economy.

Amex Travel Portal – Porter Reserve is marketed and sold as Premium Economy

Inconsistent Availability

As Porter is still expanding its fleet and routes, Porter Reserve is not yet available on all flights. This can be frustrating for frequent travelers looking for a consistent experience.

Limited Entertainment and Baggage Options

Although the flight provides complimentary Wi-Fi, the lack of seatback entertainment screens may disappoint travelers accustomed to more robust in-flight entertainment systems. While Porter Reserve includes checked baggage, the weight allowances are stricter than those offered by some competitors in similar classes.

The Points Guru Final Thoughts

Porter Reserve on the Toronto to Vancouver route delivers a comfortable and enjoyable experience, blending premium service with Porter’s renowned hospitality. The spacious seating, enhanced dining, and priority perks are compelling reasons to choose this class. However, the higher price point and a few limitations in amenities and availability may give pause to some travelers. For those seeking a refined travel experience and willing to pay a bit more, Porter Reserve is a solid choice, especially for domestic flights in Canada. However, travelers should weigh the pros and cons based on their specific needs and budget.

Have you tried Porter Reserve or are considering it for an upcoming trip? Share your thoughts and questions in the comments below!